Skip to content

Choosing Between Wooden Vs Plastic Toilet Seats

Both wooden and plastic toilet seats have their own benefits and they both last about the same amount of time on average so price really does not matter when deciding which type you want to be installed in your home. Depending on the type of wood or plastic, you might have one that is lighter than the other which will make cleaning under it easier. Wooden seats can be painted or stained to match your bathroom and they are waterproof so they do not absorb moisture as plastic ones do.

Wooden seats come in different shapes and designs such as elongated and round while plastic ones only come in one design which means the fit may not be perfect even if it works for your toilet bowl. Plastic toilet seats usually lose their finish over time but some wooden ones do too depending on what finish you choose when buying them.

The material used determines how long a toilet seat lasts and how well it holds up to daily wear and tear. There is no clear answer when deciding between wooden vs plastic toilet seats because they both have their own benefits and drawbacks. Prices for wooden versus plastic toilet seats are similar while the type of seat you choose should be based on personal preference and your bathroom design.

Wooden Toilet Seats

Home+Solutions Toilet Seat, Round, Distressed Wood

Home+Solutions Toilet Seat, Round, Distressed Wood

Looking to update your bathroom? Freshen up your décor with our distressed wood Home+Solutions Toilet Seat. Distressed wood does not have an unfinished look, it provides a great rustic touch that is stylish and natural. This seat is perfect for any home’s needs whether you are looking for something sturdy or an updated appearance. Sturdy construction made from soft-close hinges will keep this toilet seat securely attached to your toilet without the need to tighten constantly. Round, white toothbrush holders can also be used on this model making it easier than ever before to store away all of those necessities too! The slow-close lid and seat glide gently closed providing less sound and preserving privacy which we know everyone appreciates; no more slamming lids or seats!

Installation is also quick and easy so you can get right to your project instead of waiting around for days. This seat has the perfect blend of style, function, and affordability that will give any bathroom a refreshing new feel. Whether you are looking to outfit one bathroom or every bathroom in your home this durable toilet seat by Home+Solutions is just what you need.

Design House 561241 Dalton Round Toilet Seat

Design House 561241 Dalton Round Toilet Seat

Leaving a lot to the imagination, the Design House 561241 Dalton Round Toilet Seat provides everything you need and nothing more. Smooth lines and traditional design give this seat an eye-catching antique look, perfect for bringing your bathroom back in time. With a weight limit of up to 600 lbs, you can rest assured that everyone will find relief on this seat! It also comes installed with both standard mounts and hidden screws so installation is always quick and easy. Powder-coated steel ensures that you never have to worry about rust or corrosion giving out early breakdowns! This seat offers peace of mind without sacrificing style or any high-quality finish product. What are you waiting for? Add some old-fashioned charm to your home’s newest addition today!

MAYFAIR 19601CP 378 Toilet Seat with Chrome Hinges, Elongated

MAYFAIR 19601CP 378 Toilet Seat with Chrome Hinges, Elongated

When it comes to the beauty of your bathroom, nothing beats wood. It’s durable and natural. The MAYFAIR 19601CP 378 toilet seat with chrome hinges has a rich WOOD FINISH that will never crack or split in a way plastic could over time. With its CLASSIC CHROME HINGES, this product is always going well with any style bathroom décor from mid-century modern to traditional to contemporary—in either color! And because it fits all elongated toilets,—including Kohler-, American Standard-, TOTO- and many others,—the MAYFAIR 19601CP 378 toilet seat is perfect for any manor home design project large or small.

Plastic Toilet Seats

Kohler K-4639-0 Cachet Round White Toilet Seat

Kohler K-4639-0 Cachet Round White Toilet Seat

The new Cachet Round White Toilet Seat by Kohler is the latest addition to our already impressive toilet seat collection. With its grip tight bumpers, quick-release hinges, and chrome hardware, this new round plastic toilet seat is sure to be a hit with any homeowner looking for some style in their bathroom – without sacrificing comfort. Oh! And did you notice the soft close lid? No more slamming of that pesky thing into the porcelain god forbid you to leave it open all night long! It’ll gently close without making noise if your hands are full or tendering an urgent need arises.. We’ve all been there. Now feel free to enjoy a nice hot shower after getting rid of business without waking up the whole house in the morning!

BEMIS 70 346 Toilet Seat, ROUND

BEMIS 70 346 Toilet Seat, ROUND

When it comes time to replace your old toilet seat, make an environmentally friendly and quality choice. BEMIS is proud of her American-made products and even prouder when she installs a new toilet seat in your home! From the durable hard plastic that won’t chip or scratch over time, to the glued-in color that resists stains and wear. And with top-notch hinges that install from above (making installation super easy!) there’s no reason not to do something nice for yourself. You deserve it.

Buying a new replacement seat never had so many benefits – For you, because cleaning will be easier than ever before; for our environment because we made this product using Earth-friendly materials and craftsmanship; and for our economy, because we’re proud to be an American company that has been proudly making quality products since 1932! This is not just a toilet seat – It’s the Bemis Difference.

Delta Faucet Morgan Round Front Slow-Close

Delta Faucet Morgan Round Front Slow-Close

The slow-close toilet seat closes quietly and helps to prevent slamming.  The non-slip toilet seat bumpers keep the seat from moving or shifting. This white toilet seat fits most round-front toilet bowls. The fast and secure installation helps prevent loosening. The durable finish is resistant to staining, fading, chipping, and peeling.”

The durable lifespan of our product will save you time in the long run since replacing it every few years will not be necessary.

What to Consider When Choosing a Toilet Seat

If you are on the market for a new toilet seat, there are some different things to consider before choosing one. Which material do you want it to be made of? Do you prefer if it is wooden or plastic? How much are you willing to spend on the new seat? All of these questions should be answered before making your purchase. Here are some things to keep in mind when looking at different seats so you can choose the best one for your bathroom.

Toilet Seat Style

First, you need to decide what kind of toilet seat style do you want. There are five different styles: round front, elongated front, round closed front, Elongated Closed Front, and contoured seats. Round and Elongated Closed Fronts come in both wood and plastic. If you have a round bowl or one that is close to the same size as the seat itself, then a round-fronted seat should fit just fine. However, if your bowl is elongated then an elongated fronted seat will be necessary for the best fit. A wooden seat with a contour or molded shape can help prevent your legs from hitting the side of the toilet while sitting down.

Toilet Seat Comfort

Second, think about the comfort level of the seat. One way to increase comfort is by using a toilet seat with padding. A padded seat will feel much more comfortable than one without padding or cushioning.

Toilet Seat Durability

Third, think about how durable this new seat needs to be so it can last you for years to come. The material that is used in making the seat, wood or plastic, will determine how long-lasting it becomes. Wooden seats are very sturdy and can last up to 20 years or longer if it is taken care of properly and kept out of moisture. Plastic seats are not as sturdy because they break over time if they are not taken proper care of but they are much lighter which makes them easier to lift off when cleaning.

Toilet Seat Warmth

Fourth, think about warmth. Wooden seats can either be painted or stained to give them a color of your choice. Stained toilet seats will absorb heat better than painted ones which means the seat stays warmer for longer periods of time.

Toilet Seat Weight

Fifth, you are going to want to consider the weight. Plastic seats are easier to lift off because they are much lighter than wooden ones but most wooden toilet seats have an extra-wide design with larger hinges that help make them stronger and more durable since they don’t break as easily. There are also plastic seats with large hinges that will not bend under pressure if you apply too much force while removing it from the bowl. It is important to keep in mind that weight, durability, and how easily it can be removed are all necessary factors when choosing a new toilet seat.

Toilet Seat Cleaning

Sixth, you should think about the cleaning process of both types of seats. Wooden seats come in different finishes so you can choose one that is easy to clean. Most wooden seats have a coating on them which makes them easier to wipe off with soap and water if they get dirty. Plastic ones do not always need to be cleaned as often because the finish will wear off over time but sometimes dirt or stains can be difficult if not impossible to remove from plastic seats without ruining them at the same time.

Frequently Asked Questions

Should the toilet seat be left up, down, or closed and why?

The toilet seat should always be left down when not in use. Leaving it up will make your toilet vulnerable to bacteria which can cause certain diseases if exited on the toilet seat. Closing it however is also not recommended since you are not allowing airflow between yourself and the lid, trapping unwanted odor inside the bowl.

How do you clean a wooden toilet seat?

Wooden toilet seats are usually easy to clean by simply wiping them with a damp cloth or cleaning wipe. For stubborn stains, try using baking soda or vinegar solution for deep cleansing of tougher stains. Do not use bleach since it may discolor your wood and damage your toilets finish over time.

What's the solution for cold toilet seats?

The solution is to purchase a toilet seat cover. This will provide you with the comfort that your toilet bowl also has the added benefit of providing you extra warmth during those cold winter nights by trapping in some of the heat from your sink, bathtub or shower.

What are some ways to keep chilled wood toilet seats warm?

There are many ways you can go about keeping your wooden toilet seats warm. One is of course, purchase of a heated toilet seat which you simply plug into an outlet under your sink so that once plugged in it provides instant warmth for several hours after which you just simply unplug and place it back inside its storage box until next use! Another way would be to install a more permanent fixture for heating purposes by running electric wiring from your sink, bathtub or shower and installing a switch for turning the toilet seat warmer on and off.


Plastic is the best material for creating toilet seats because it can be easily molded into different shapes and colors. Wood, on the other hand, may be polished to prevent stains and scratches but over time becomes chipped and damaged with exposure to water. Wooden toilet seats also become very cold in winter months due to its lack of insulation compared to plastic that traps heat from sinks and showers. Plastic is lighter than wood allowing sanitary workers to lift it more easily onto the toilet bowl without needing assistance from others whereas wooden toilet seats must frequently be lifted by several people at once and carried as a whole unit often resulting in injuries or breakage.